1997-98 VisCom Assessment Report
The School of Visual Communication offers an interdisciplinary degree with five specialized sequences. The program is designed to provide students with realistic and
thorough broad-based professionally oriented training in visual communication, while providing the necessary liberal arts and cultural background for a strong educational foundation.
Intensive training is offered in photojournalism for newspapers and magazines, picture editing, photo illustration, interactive multimedia, and informational graphics/publication design.
Goals of the School
The goals of the School of Visual Communication are (1) to equip students with the necessary skills to be successful in the media, and the background and motivation to enable them to
compete for leadership roles in the field; (2) to provide assistance and professional guidance in visual communication to working photographers, editors, and other personnel together with newspapers, press services, magazines, industrial photographic departments, trade associations, multimedia and educational media production units, and cultural and scientific visual communicators; (3) to set high standards for visual integrity and communication ethics; and (4) to foster and promote scholarly research and creative activity among our students.
Derived from our mission statement and our roots in the School of Art and School of Journalism, the schools curriculum is interdisciplinary requiring core classes in three schools; Visual Communication, Art and Journalism. Over the last five years the curriculum has evolved with changes in the profession. Sources of curricular assessment include feedback from students, analysis of competing programs, and input from working professionals.
With only six faculty members VisCom is able to quickly fine-tune curriculum when the need arises. The faculty has designed the following elements in the schools curriculum:
Writing skills Essays and/or reports are required in all classes (including technical skills courses)
Verbal Skills In addition to researching and writing reports, students are required to make oral presentations of their findings. They are also required to participate in class critiques.
Computer literacy None of our majors will flourish professionally without solid computer skills. To meet this need all 300 level and above courses include a computer lab component.
Ethics component The easy access to digital technology has made ethical considerations increasingly important to visual communicators. This fact has prompted our faculty to place renewed emphasis on ethical discussions and classroom exercises.
Technical mastery As a professional program technical skills are always present in classroom instruction and assignments.
Visual creativity All professional course grading includes a visual creativity score to ensure aesthetic growth and development.
Critical thinking Technical skills are not enough to ensure good employment opportunities for our graduates. Employers demand the ability to make quick intelligent decisions. Each course has a realistic problem-solving component. The student is required to determine their own creative approach to class assignments.
To monitor and assess student progress the School of Visual Communication has utilized a wide variety of assessment tools:
Student outcome
Charting of Student employment success
Student academic achievement
Alumni accomplishment
Faculty evaluators
Quarterly faculty roundtable discussion to assess individual class successes and disappointments.
Capstone Course Evaluation
A faculty juried student show (first one was hung in April, 1998)
Capstone projects in three of five sequences (photo communication, page design & multimedia) involving 90% of all VisCom majors
Student Projects
School-wide student projects offered outside of the classroom environment encourage crossover between the schools major sequences. These projects offer students an opportunity to work in a team on an active learning project.
Student Portfolios
All classes above the 300 level require portfolio submission at the completion of the class.
External evaluation
VisCom tracks student successes in major student and professional competitions to gauge the intellectual and creative skills of our past and present students.
Professional experience Students are required to complete a paid professional internship before they graduate.
Exposure to professional trends Each quarter professional visual communicators are invited to address our students both in and out of classroom environments. These professionals are asked to appraise student work.
One of the largest websites on the universitys network (over 1500 pages) is a public forum for discussion and feedback on student work.
Internal evaluation
Institutional research compendium data is used together with departmental assessment surveys.
Pre/Post Evaluation
Starting with the incoming freshman class (1998-99) all students will be asked to complete a questionnaire assessing their expectations, surveying why they selected Ohio University and the School of Visual Communication.
Exit interviews Informal exit interviews with small groups of graduating seniors and graduate students have been used in the past to gauge program success. Starting with the graduating class of 1999 all seniors and graduate students will participate in a formal interview with the school director.
Alumni are periodically surveyed by the office of institutional research.
VisCom maintains an area on our website to showcase former students work and achievements.
(see: http://www.viscom.ohiou.edu/alumni/home.html)
Qualitative and quantitative indicators of excellence
College Photographer of the Year Competition
The College Photographer of the Year contest is the premiere college photo contest in the United States. The contest is in its 50th year and is sponsored by The University of Missouri School of Journalism, Canon USA and Eastman Kodak.
For two years in a row The School of Visual Communication has won more awards in this contest than any other school in the United States. This year VisCom students won 28 awards which amounted to 30% of all the awards. Included in the awards was the College Photographer of the Year and three of the five awards in the portfolio category. (see addendum # 1)
Pictures of the Year Competition
The Pictures of the Year competition is open to professional photographers around the world. Student photographers can enter, but rarely win. This year two VisCom graduate students won awards in this prestigious contest.
The Macromedia Software Company, creators of Freehand, Director, Shockwave, and other industry standard software, highlights the work of School of Visual Communication students on their website.
(See: http://www.macromedia.com/software/freehand/gallery/edgallery/ohio/index.html)
The Hearst Foundation 1997 Photojournalism Competition
VisCom student winners in this annual contest for college students majoring in Photojournalism took:
8th place in Competition I
11th place in Competition II
11th place in Competition III
11th place in Competition III
Digital publishing on the internet
The VisCom website encompasses over 1500 pages (http://www.viscom.ohiou.edu). It includes all the schoolwide cross-discipline projects (Dawn to Dusk in Nelsonville, Dawn to Dusk in Athens and Halloween 96) plus over 30 student portfolios and resumes. Class notes for over a half a dozen classes are on the web providing students with immediate access to class information.
One student received an internship offer from a newspaper to which they had not applied after the students work was viewed on the VisCom website.
Internship database
The School of Visual Communication maintains a searchable internship database with over 440 entries. The database will be added to our website this summer to provide students with the option of searching the database at anytime from anywhere they have internet access.
Internship placement
VisCom requires a paid internship of all students. Approximately 50 graduate and undergraduate students need internships each calendar year. With the placement assistance of the faculty, VisCom students completed 87 internships in the last calendar year. This exceeds by 57% the number needed by graduating students. These internships were in 22 different states, the District of Columbia and one in Finland.
Outstanding skills make our students very desirable in the workplace as indicated by these placement figures. (Please see addendum #3.)
The Adobe Student Design Contest
A graduate student won first place in the photorealistic images category of this international student design contest. The student's work will be displayed on the Adobe website (http://www.adobe.com) in July.
Eddie Adams Workshop Participants
Students are chosen for this national workshop by portfolio review by a committee of working professionals. VisCom had six students chosen for the 1997 workshop.
One student was chosen as outstanding workshop participant, and another student was awarded an internship in the photo department of The White House based on his/her performance in the workshop.
Seventh Annual Collegiate Sports Journalism Seminar Participants
Fifty college sports journalists are selected from across the nation to participate in this workshop conducted by professional sports journalists.
VisCom had three students selected.
Knight Foundation Fellowships
The Knight Foundation, established by the Knight-Ridder media corporation, awarded a $250,000 grant to The School of Visual Communication to establish the Knight Fellowship in newsroom graphics management.
This fellowship, the only one of its kind in the United States, has brought to campus some outstanding mid-career professionals as graduate fellows.
Pulitzer Prize in Photography
The pinnacle of a professional journalists career is to win a Pulitzer Prize. This years Pulitzer Prize in spot news photography was awarded to a VisCom graduate of The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. VisCom has a strong Pulitzer presence in our schools faculty and students.
Talent & Academic Scholarships
$28,489 from internal and external sources was awarded to VisCom students in 1998.
Morris Berman Scholarship (Awarded by the The Pittsburgh Press Photographers Association) $500
Larry Fullerton Memorial Scholarship (Awarded by the The Ohio News Photographers Association) $1,500
Kit King Scholarship (Awarded by the The National Press Photographers Association) $500
Scripps Howard Foundation Scholarships - 10 - $500.00 Scholarships
Deans Office Scholarships - 3 - $2,000.00 Scholarships
- 1 - $1,500.00 Scholarship
- 5 - $1,000.00 Scholarships
- 1 - $300.00 Scholarship
Urda Traenkle Memorial Scholarship - $1689.00
Deans Office Special Talent Award Scholarship - $2,000
Kodak Professional Photography Scholarship - $1,500
Paul Schutzer Scholarship - $1,500
Enrollment Figures (from Institutional Research Compendium Reports)
Undergraduate headcount by major:
1992 - 104 1993 - 124 1994 - 152 1995 - 173 1996 - 205 1997 - 254
Program excellence has resulted in enrollment more than doubling in less than 6 years.
Graduate school applicants for 1998-99 academic year: 50 (22 admissions)
Increase from previous academic year - 70%
VisCom Annual Assessment Survey 1998 Results
In June of 1998 VisCom conducted the first of an annual survey of student
The School of Visual Communication is constantly making an effort to improve the quality of education and opportunities available to our students. In an effort to improve even further we surveyed students to find out how we are doing and how they feel about their college education.
The survey asked them to rate things such as; internal communication, advising, school activities, their academic process and internship experiences.
The overal ratings are listed below and the full breakdown by class rank is included in addendum #2.
How would you rate your college experience? Poor Average Excellent
1% 33% 66%
How would you rate your advising experience in VisCom?
Poor Average Excellent3% 39% 57%
Have faculty been available when you needed them?
Yes No 94% 6%What is your overall feelings about VisCom?
Poor Average Excellent 0% 24% 76%Have you enjoyed your college experience at Ohio University?
Yes No 98% 2%Have you enjoyed your college experience in VisCom?
Yes No 97% 3%Have you participated in any of the VisCom special events and/or activities? (e.g. Dawn to Dusk, NPPA speakers, OUSND, Advising meetings, Communications Week, etc.)
Yes No
88% 12%
How would you rate the faculty?
Poor Average Excellent 0% 11% 89%Have you had an internship or have you accepted one?
Yes No51% 49%
Did the faculty help you find your internship?
Yes No40% 60%
If you have had an internship, did you find the experience beneficial?
Yes No86% 14%
Have you used the internship directories in the VisCom office?
Yes No57% 43%
How would you rate VisComs communication with students?
Poor Average Excellent 0% 22% 78%Have you visited the VisCom website?
Yes No 85% 15%Do you get the email announcements from VisCom?
Yes No 90% 10%Do you consider them important or a waste of time?
Important Waste of Time 96% 4%Do you expect to graduate on time?
Yes No 61% 39%Do you see your advisor every quarter?
Yes No 64% 36%Do you attend the VisCom advising sessions?
Yes No 82% 18%If you do attend, do you find the meetings helpful?
Yes No 91% 9%How would you rate VisCom as a school?
Poor Average Excellent0% 18% 82%
Do you feel that your VisCom degree will provide you with the proper background to compete successfully in the job market when you graduate?
Yes No 95% 5%Have you used any of the College of Communication students services?
Yes No 34% 66%Did you attend any of the VisCom activities during Communication Week?
Yes No 85% 15%Did you attend the opening of the VisCom Student Show?
Yes No 57% 43%Should VisCom have a student show next year?
Yes No 100% 0%1997-98 Visiting Professionals
Picture Editor, The Chicago Tribune
Photographer, The Chicago Tribune
Design Director, America Online
Pulitzer Prize winner, Photographer, The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Digital Artist, Myst
National Geographic Staff Photographer
Photographer, Copley Newspapers (1998 Pulitzer finalist)
Design Director, The Detroit Free Press
Photographer, Block Newspapers (1998 Pulitzer finalist)
Staff Photographer, The Palm Beach Post
Staff Photographer, The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Future needs/expectations
All programs will have capstone courses implemented within two years.
Freshmen expectation surveys will commence in the summer of 1998.
Graduate exit interviews will begin with 1998-99 graduates.
Rapid increase in enrollment numbers has placed burdens on faculty workload and class size. Measures to eleviate the overcrowding must be addressed with either increased resources or a ceiling on enrollment.
A renewed effort to encourage student participation in the advising process must be addressed.
This document is also available online at: http://www.viscom.ohiou.edu/viscom/asess97.html
Submitted by the Faculty of The School of Visual Communication.